Sherrod Brown and a Review of US Senators Holding Both Senate Seats

The tenure of fewer than two-dozen U.S. Senators includes service in each of their state’s seats during the direct election era

Thanks to Smart Politics reader Brad K. for inquiring about this topic.

With Democrats looking to expand the 2026 map as large as possible to pry away enough GOP-held U.S. Senate seats to win back control of the chamber, one of the states they hope to flip is Ohio – where recently unseated Sherrod Brown is poised to face appointed incumbent Jon Husted.

Brown, a former three-term U.S. Senator from the state’s Class I seat, is attempting to become the 23rd member of the chamber to serve in each of his state’s senate seats during the direct election era.

Over the last 223 years since statehood, four Ohioans have served in the U.S. Senate from both seats, with Democrat Howard Metzenbaum the only one to do so since the 1800s.

Metzenbaum was appointed to the Class III seat in January 1974 by Governor John Gilligan following the resignation of Republican William Saxbe to become U.S. Attorney General.

Metzenbaum then lost the Democratic primary that cycle to retired astronaut John Glenn but won his party’s nomination to the Class I seat in 1976 and returned to D.C. by unseating Robert Taft, Jr. in the general election in a rematch of the 1970 contest.

Three Ohio U.S. Senators served in both seats prior to the direct election era:

• Democratic-Republican Thomas Worthington: 1803-1807 (Class III) and 1810-1814 (Class I)
• Anti-Jacksonian / Whig Thomas Ewing: 1831-1837 (Class III) and 1850-1851 (Class I)
• Republican John Sherman: 1861-1877 (Class III) and 1881-1897 (Class I)

Arizona’s Jon Kyl was the most recent U.S. Senator to accomplish this feat across the nation following his appointment by Governor Doug Ducey in September 2018 to fill the vacancy after John McCain’s death. Kyl served four months in the Class III seat, having previously held office from 1995 to 2013 in the Class I seat.

Three other U.S. Senators served from both seats with at least one stint partially in the 21st Century:

• Washington Republican Slade Gorton: 1981-1987 (Class III) and 1989-2001 (Class I)
• North Dakota Democrat Kent Conrad: 1987-1992 (Class III) and 1992-2013 (Class I)
• New Jersey Democrat Frank Lautenberg: 1982-2001 (Class I) and 2003-2013 (Class II)

Brown would be the first U.S. Senator whose tenure in both seats fell entirely during the 21st Century.

Four states have had two U.S. Senators hold both seats during the direct election era.

Iowa:

• Republican Smith Brookhart: 1922-1926 (Class II) and 1927-1933 (Class III)
• Democrat Guy Gillette: 1936-1945 (Class III) and 1949-1955 (Class II)

Massachusetts:

• Democrat David Walsh: 1919-1925 (Class II) and 1926-1947 (Class I)
• Republican Henry Cabot Lodge, Jr.: 1937-1944 (Class II) and 1947-1953 (Class I)

New Jersey:

• Republican Warren Barbour: 1931-1937 (Class II) and 1938-1943 (Class I)
• Democrat Frank Lautenberg: 1982-2001 (Class I) and 2003-2013 (Class II)

West Virginia:

• Democrat Matthew Neely: 1923-1929 (Class I) and 1931-1941 (Class II)
• Republican Chapman Revercomb: 1943-1949 (Class II) and 1956-1959 (Class I)

The remaining U.S. Senators who represented their states from each seat are:

• Oklahoma Democrat Thomas Gore: 1907-1921 (Class III) and 1931-1937 (Class II)
• Delaware Republican T. Coleman du Pont: 1921-1922 (Class I) and 1925-1928 (Class II)
• Kentucky Democrat Alben Barkley: 1927-1949 (Class III) and 1955-1956 (Class II)
• Idaho Republican John Thomas: 1928-1933 (Class III) and 1940-1945 (Class II)
• Wyoming Democrat Joseph O’Mahoney: 1934-1953 (Class I) and 1954-1961 (Class II)
• Indiana Republican William Jenner: 1944-1945 (Class III) and 1947-1959 (Class I)
• Minnesota DFLer Hubert Humphrey: 1949-1964 (Class II) and 1971-1978 (Class I)
• Connecticut Republican William Purtell: 1952 (Class III) and 1953-1959 (Class I)
• Arizona Republican Barry Goldwater: 1953-1965 (Class I) and 1969-1987 (Class III)
• Texas Democrat William Blakley: 1957 (Class I) and 1961 (Class II)

The aforementioned North Dakotan Kent Conrad is of note because he moved from the state’s Class III to Class I seat in 1992 without a gap in service – unlike the other senators listed in this report.

Follow Smart Politics on X.