Ilhan Omar Records Another Historically Close Primary Win
Only six of the 162 renomination bids by DFL U.S. Representatives have been decided by less than 30 points – Omar now owns three of them
Two years after recording the weakest primary victory by a Minnesota DFL U.S. Representative in party history, Congresswoman Ilhan Omar slightly improved her standing in the district, but still ended up with a winning margin that was historically thin.
Omar defeated former Minneapolis City Councilman Don Samuels by 13.3 points in Tuesday’s rematch from 2022 – which goes down as the fifth narrowest win by a DFL U.S. Representative since the party merger in 1944.
It is also the fifth narrowest win by any Democratic Minnesota U.S. Representative dating back to the first U.S. House primaries in the state in 1902.
Since, 1944, DFL U.S. Representatives have sought renomination 162 times with 53 drawing an opponent and 109 running unopposed. All were victorious.
In each of these 53 contested races, the incumbent won renomination by an average margin of 63.8 points.
In fact, DFL U.S. Representatives have won renomination by less than 30 points just six times over the last 80 years – and Rep. Omar now owns three of those.
Omar set the party record for the closest primary win in 2022 when she defeated Samuels by just 2.15 points.
In 2020, Omar had defeated attorney and political novice Antone Melton-Meaux by 19.7 points in a race that received much more national attention.
The 2022 Samuels vs. Omar contest broke the previous mark set 30 years prior in the state’s 6th Congressional District recorded by five-term incumbent Gerry Sikorski in 1992 (Anoka, Dakota, and Washington Counties).
Sikorski, however, was in the midst of the U.S. House Banking Scandal that cycle, in which many members from both parties were found to have overdrafts on their accounts – some, including Sikorski – for hundreds of checks.
As a result, Sikorski drew three challengers in the DFL primary and defeated former state Senator Tad Jude by just 2.89 points. [Sikorski would subsequently lose the general election to Rod Grams].
Besides Omar and Sikorski, no other DFLer has won renomination by less than double digits and just two others also failed to win by 30+ points:
- 1958 (9th CD): Two-term Rep. Coya Knudson defeated Marvin Evenson by 12.4 points
- 1980 (8th CD): Three-term Rep. Jim Oberstar beat Tom Dougherty by 11.3 points
The last time a U.S. House member from any party in Minnesota won by less than Omar’s 2.15-point margin in 2022 was in the 1922 3rd CD primary.
In that cycle, 10-term Republican Charles Davis beat Washington County Attorney Reuben Thoreen by 2.11 points in a head-to-head matchup.
Follow Smart Politics on X/Twitter.
Since 2019-2020, it has become routine to closely follow the electoral slogs of Representatives Omar for the determinative DFL primary election and DFLer “Angie” Craig for the general election (for the only closely divided constituency of the state).
True, the primary win by Omar – the only meaningful election of the district – is a relatively perilous one, but hey, at least she did not end up joining fellow “Squad” comrades Cori Bush and Jamaal Bowman in defeat (both of whom had made themselves ripe for political extinction long before the pro-Zionist UDP maneuvered to aid their principal opponents with baleful of moolahs).
I don’t know if it’s a glitch but I’ve had a few times when my comment won’t post so I type it once more and then the original 1 posts later as a result I got 2 posts that say the same thing. Again I don’t know if it’s a glitch but I thought I’d bring it up.